WASHINGTON, Sept. 17 (UPI) — The U.S. Justice Department said seven states are backing efforts to stop AT&T’s purchase of T-Mobile, which would create the nation’s largest phone carrier. In a statement, the department said, “We have an excellent working
Joel Tenenbaum, the Boston University student whose file-sharing proclivities got him sued by the major music labels, owes them $675,000. Again.
Tenenbaum’s trial, the second such file-sharing trial in the country, ended with a $675,000 jury verdict against him. Judge Nancy Gertner cut the award to $67,500, following the same path blazed by the first judge to hear such a case, but with one crucial difference: rather than rely on “remittitur,” in which a judge can simply lower the monetary amount of a jury award, Gertner went right to the Constitution. The award was so astronomical, she said, that it violated the US Constitution and had to be reduced. ($67,500 was as high as Judge Gertner said was permissible.)
The recording industry appealed this decision; early Friday evening, they won a round. The First Circuit Court of Appeals agreed (PDF) that Judge Gertner had jumped to the Constitutional question too quickly. Though the appellate judges applauded her handling of the trial, they wrote that Gertner “should first have considered the non-constitutional issue of remittitur, which may have obviated any constitutional due process issue and attendant issues. Had the court ordered remittitur of a particular amount, Sony would have then had a choice. It could have accepted the reduced award. Or, it could have rejected the remittitur, in which case a new trial would have ensued.”
Only if remittitur failed to resolve the case would Gertner be justified in moving on to the larger issue of unconstitutionality.
Remittitur did fail the first file-sharing trial target, Jammie Thomas-Rasset in Minnesota. After three full trials and two judicial overrides, Judge Michael Davis finally reached the constitutional question and declared the award against Thomas-Rasset unacceptable. That decision has now been appealed.
We might well see the same thing with the Tenenbaum lawsuit, but for now, the original $675,000 judgment has been reinstated.
The Appeals Court hinted that, though its decision was procedurally proper, it didn’t support such harsh penalties against Tenenbaum. “We comment that this case raises concerns about application of the Copyright Act which Congress may wish to examine,” wrote the judges.
At least nine people were killed when a vintage plane crashed at an air race near Reno, Nevada, police say, as investigators launch a probe.
The BlackBerry PlayBook is a disaster, and not just because sales have collapsed. The Waterloo, Ontario-based company sold shipped 200,000 of the tablet computers last quarter, down from 500,000 during the earlier quarter. No, it’s worse than that. BlackBerry can’t afford to exit the tablet
How much money would you be willing to pay for one game? Our most popular story looked at the most expensive NES game on the market, and the stories behind the golden cart. We also reviewed both Hard Reset and Gears of War 3.
Come in, and take a look at the stories you may have missed this week.
With just thirteen months to go before the 2012 presidential elections, Republicans are more confident than ever that they will defeat President Barack Obama. But the more scrutiny their field of candidates receives, the more people are asking, “Is this the best they can do?”